Robohub.org
 

FAA regulations draw inspiration from Canada, but miss key aspect


by
19 February 2015



share this:
Source: Wikipedia

Source: Wikipedia

Various aspects of the anticipated proposed small UAS (sUAS) regulations that were released by the FAA draw inspiration from Canada’s approach to regulation. In fact, the FAA provides a handy comparison chart on pgs. 55-56. The Canadian comparison is limited to Canada’s new exemptions for sUAS.

Canada’s exemptions operate very differently than FAA exemptions, as they do not require approval from our regulator, Transport Canada.

If you meet the requirements of either of Canada’s two exemptions, you can operate without applying for a Special Flight Operations Certificate (SFOC). SFOC allow for broader applications than what is shown in the FAA comparison chart, including FPV and beyond visual line of sight.

Practicing in the Canadian jurisdiction, I believe that one of the most valuable aspects of our system is its flexibility and the fact that the system rewards safe operators. For instance, in Canada, first time SFOC applicants are typically rewarded narrow certificates in terms of time, geography and level of operational risk. As operators develop a track record of conducting safe operations, they are able to receive ‘standing certificates’ allowing them to operate for up to three years over large regions of the country.

The FAA should consider adopting a similar approach that rewards safe operators by allowing them to complete less restrictive operations. For instance, the proposed rules state that operators would not be able to fly over persons not involved in the operation. If an operator has a good track record of conducting safe flights, there is no reason why the FAA should not consider removing this burden.

As the FAA crafts its final regulations, it is important to find ways to build flexibility into the system, and to not only focus on punishing irresponsible behaviour but also rewarding safe operators.



tags: , , ,


Diana Marina Cooper is Vice President of Legal and Policy Affairs at PrecisionHawk.
Diana Marina Cooper is Vice President of Legal and Policy Affairs at PrecisionHawk.

            AUAI is supported by:



Subscribe to Robohub newsletter on substack



Related posts :

Robot Talk Episode 171 – Programming robot behaviour, with Sebastian Castro

  20 Nov 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Sebastian Castro about developing open-source software for robot task planning and behaviour.

Soft exosuit makes it easier to stand up

Robotic system helps users stand up and walk more efficiently.

Robot swarms trained by trial and error in simulation keep working on real robots

  17 Nov 2026
Researchers have developed a new approach to reinforcement learning that helps robot swarms, allowing behaviours learned in simulation to transfer reliably to real-world robots.

Watch the IROS 2026 plenary and keynote talks

  16 Nov 2026
Catch up on the invited presentations from the International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems.

Robot Talk Episode 170 – Robots in the real world, with Daniela Shchegelskaya

  13 Nov 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Daniela Shchegelskaya from the University of Twente about getting robots to operate reliably in safety-critical environments.

AI100 report released: embodied AI highlighted as grand challenge

  11 Nov 2026
Embodied AI is listed as one of the most inspiring open grand challenges.

AIhub coffee corner: Are humanoids the future of embodied AI?

  09 Nov 2026
The AIhub coffee corner captures the musings of AI experts over a short conversation.

Robot Talk Episode 169 – Robot sensing inspired by nature, with Dexter Shepherd

  06 Nov 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Dexter Shepherd from the University of Sussex about using artificial intelligence to help robots understand and adapt to their environment.


↑


AUAI is supported by:







Subscribe to Robohub newsletter on substack




 















©2026.05 - Association for the Understanding of Artificial Intelligence