Robohub.org
 

Here’s a terrible idea: Robot cars with adjustable ethics settings | Patrick Lin via WIRED


by
21 August 2014



share this:

Why not let the user select the car’s “ethics setting”? The way this would work is one customer may set the car (which he paid for) to jealously value his life over all others; another user may prefer that the car values all lives the same and minimizes harm overall; yet another may want to minimize legal liability and costs for herself; and other settings are possible.

Plus, with an adjustable ethics dial set by the customer, the manufacturer presumably can’t be blamed for hard judgment calls, especially in no-win scenarios, right?

Even if an ethics setting lets the company off the hook, guess what? We, the users, may then be solely responsible for injury or death in an unavoidable accident. At best, an ethics setting merely punts responsibility from manufacturer to customer, but it still doesn’t make progress toward that responsibility.

In an important sense, any injury that results from our ethics setting may be premeditated if it’s foreseen.

Read more by Patrick Lin on WIRED.

If you liked this article, you might also be interested in our Reader polls on autonomous cars, some of which were cited in this piece.




Hallie Siegel robotics editor-at-large
Hallie Siegel robotics editor-at-large





Related posts :

Sven Koenig wins the 2026 ACM/SIGAI Autonomous Agents Research Award

  10 Feb 2026
Sven honoured for his work on AI planning and search.

Robot Talk Episode 143 – Robots for children, with Elmira Yadollahi

  06 Feb 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Elmira Yadollahi from Lancaster University about how children interact with and relate to robots.

New frontiers in robotics at CES 2026

  03 Feb 2026
Henry Hickson reports on the exciting developments in robotics at Consumer Electronics Show 2026.

Robot Talk Episode 142 – Collaborative robot arms, with Mark Gray

  30 Jan 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Mark Gray from Universal Robots about their lightweight robotic arms that work alongside humans.

Robot Talk Episode 141 – Our relationship with robot swarms, with Razanne Abu-Aisheh

  23 Jan 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Razanne Abu-Aisheh from the University of Bristol about how people feel about interacting with robot swarms.

Vine-inspired robotic gripper gently lifts heavy and fragile objects

  23 Jan 2026
The new design could be adapted to assist the elderly, sort warehouse products, or unload heavy cargo.

Robot Talk Episode 140 – Robot balance and agility, with Amir Patel

  16 Jan 2026
In the latest episode of the Robot Talk podcast, Claire chatted to Amir Patel from University College London about designing robots with the agility and manoeuvrability of a cheetah.

Taking humanoid soccer to the next level: An interview with RoboCup trustee Alessandra Rossi

and   14 Jan 2026
Find out more about the forthcoming changes to the RoboCup soccer leagues.


Robohub is supported by:





 













©2026.01 - Association for the Understanding of Artificial Intelligence