Robohub.org
 

We Robot Conference: 6. Manufacturer risk management

by
29 May 2013



share this:

Q: What’s the main issue that will keep the general legal counsel of a robotics company up at night? A: Massive tort liability. Maintaining that product liability is the number one issue for robot manufacturers, Stephen Wu tackled the subject of risk management at We Robot.

This post is part of Robohub’s We Robot coverage.

Paper: Risk Management in Commercializing Robots
Author: Stephen Wu
Commentator: Julie Martin

Both Wu and Martin repeatedly made the disclaimer that none of this constitutes “official” legal advice, but it’s pretty darn close. This is a highly practical, specific paper with some helpful insights for robotics manufacturers.

The paper starts with applicable legal theories, covering the range of liabilities that companies could face and the consequences thereof. Wu specifically describes the prominent Ford Pinto and Vioxx cases, and warns against giving rise to so-called “angry jurors,” Cost-benefit analyses made by companies are not always taken kindly by juries, especially when dealing with human lives, leading to very large, indemnifying verdicts.

Wu explains what manufacturers can do to preempt accidents and prevent lawsuits. Martin highlighted the advice on being proactive: going beyond what is required and beyond what is industry practice. Not just sticking to the bare minimum will signal that a company is responsible and concerned with safety. Wu also draws attention to some non-traditional risks, saying that [1] information security threats (hacking, data privacy) and [2] supply chain risks (financial fraud, security, reliability) may not be sufficiently taken into account by robotics manufacturers. Further advice in the paper includes documentation, risk management technology, helpful standards and organizations, etc.

In the discussion, Martin specifically brought up the problem of data security, stressing the importance of privacy to consumers. Technologies like telepresence robots, with recorded data, facial recognition, location tracking, etc. raise questions of privacy by design. She suggested that the framework of the paper may also be a good framework for liabilities arising from privacy issues.

There was some discussion of what jurors tend to take into account (facts, reputation, etc.), as well as the question of disclaimers and their limitations. The audience also inquired what was robotics-specific about these liability risks and ways of managing them. Martin and Wu both agreed that the general questions are not necessarily unique to robotics. But Martin made an interesting point that people might have a more visceral reaction to these issues when applied to robots. She said that this may even raise awareness and incentivize desirable risk management behavior that people should be thinking about in other industries but currently are not.

Even if automated cars are twice as good as human drivers, someone asked whether it could be a problem that companies are releasing technology that they know will more directly be responsible for a certain number of lost lives. Wu replied that manufacturers will emphasize not the number of deaths they’re taking into account, but rather the number of lives they’re saving through the technology. Martin added that many other industries have thrived in the face of similar risk management (e.g. pharmaceuticals).

Someone also brought up the development of robots that foster affection in humans and asked whether this might someday give rise to a separate liability issue. E.g. A lawsuit based on addiction to a robot’s affection and the emotional trauma of having that removed. While the audience was audibly amused, Wu agreed that such future scenarios are likely.

See all the We Robot coverage on Robohub

See also:



tags: , ,


Kate Darling





Related posts :



Robotics Today latest talks – Raia Hadsell (DeepMind), Koushil Sreenath (UC Berkeley) and Antonio Bicchi (Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia)

Robotics Today held three more online talks since we published the one from Amanda Prorok (Learning to Communicate in Multi-Agent Systems). In this post we bring you the last talks that Robotics Today (currently on hiatus) uploaded to their YouTube channel: Raia Hadsell from DeepMind talking about ‘Scalable Robot Learning in Rich Environments’, Koushil Sreenath from UC Berkeley talking about ‘Safety-Critical Control for Dynamic Robots’, and Antonio Bicchi from the Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia talking about ‘Planning and Learning Interaction with Variable Impedance’.
21 October 2021, by and

Sense Think Act Pocast: Erik Schluntz

In this episode, Audrow Nash interviews Erik Schluntz, co-founder and CTO of Cobalt Robotics, which makes a security guard robot. Erik speaks about how their robot handles elevators, how they have hum...
19 October 2021, by and

A robot that finds lost items

Researchers at MIT have created RFusion, a robotic arm with a camera and radio frequency (RF) antenna attached to its gripper, that fuses signals from the antenna with visual input from the camera to locate and retrieve an item, even if the item is buried under a pile and completely out of view.
18 October 2021, by

Robohub gets a fresh look

If you visited Robohub this week, you may have spotted a big change: how this blog looks now! On Tuesday (coinciding with Ada Lovelace Day and our ‘50 women in robotics that you need to know about‘ by chance), Robohub got a massive modernisation on its look by our technical director Ioannis K. Erripis and his team.
17 October 2021, by
ep.

339

podcast

High Capacity Ride Sharing, with Alex Wallar

In this episode, our interviewer Lilly speaks to Alex Wallar, co-founder and CTO of The Routing Company. Wallar shares his background in multi-robot path-planning and optimization, and his research on scheduling and routing algorithms for high-capacity ride-sharing. They discuss how The Routing Company helps cities meet the needs of their people, the technical ins and outs of their dispatcher and assignment system, and the importance of public transit to cities and their economics.
12 October 2021, by

50 women in robotics you need to know about 2021

It’s Ada Lovelace Day and once again we’re delighted to introduce you to “50 women in robotics you need to know about”! From the Afghanistan Girls Robotics Team to K.G.Engelhardt who in 1989 ...
12 October 2021, by and





©2021 - ROBOTS Association


 












©2021 - ROBOTS Association