Despite hard landing, Falcon 9 recovery attempt bodes well for future of reusable spacecraft

14 January 2015

share this:
autonomous spaceport drone ship (ASDS)

autonomous spaceport drone ship (ASDS)

Several hours ago, ISS astronauts opened the cargo bay of the Dragon spacecraft that was recently berthed to the space station. It was both the 7th successful Dragon mission and the 5th successful ISS dock (under NASA’s CRS program) — a perfect record, which on its own is exceptional. Dragon missions are becoming so uneventful now that they are starting to look routine. SpaceX is advancing rapidly, however, and despite this weekend’s failed attempt to recover the first stage of the Falcon9 rocket on an unmanned barge mid-ocean, it remains the most impressive feature of the ongoing CRS-5 mission.

Falcon9 v1.1 with landing legs

Falcon9 v1.1 with landing legs

Reusability is the holy grail of space systems and probably the main technology that will allow orders of magnitude in cost reduction. SpaceX first announced its reusable launch system three years ago, and significant progress has been made since then, initially with the Grasshopper experimental vehicle, then with Falcon9R dev, and since April 2014 during regular Falcon9 launches, by incorporating and testing various recovery sub-systems.

During the January 10th launch, the most ambitious step was attempted: after separating from the second stage, the first stage of the Falcon9 v1.1 rocket performed a re-orientation maneuver that ultimate lead to a controlled decent and (almost) soft landing on a specially modified unmanned ocean barge.

The recovery was only partially successful, however: the rocket descended on the barge as planned but it went down faster than expected and ultimately didn’t manage to stay on board. The rocket was lost at sea while the barge suffered minor damage. Elon Musk had previously declared that the likelihood of a successful landing was 50%, although at a later Reddit AMA admitted that he had made up the figure, stating that an attempt such as this was nothing short of highly experimental. The failure certainly provided valuable knowledge, however, and though we may not be able to calculate the chances of success for the next attempt, it will no doubt be higher.

Falcon9’s decent stage used one of its nine engines for deceleration, and a set of grid fins for additional control (you can learn more for this specific surface control design here). According to Elon Musk, the hypersonic grid system worked well but it ran out of hydraulic fluid just before touch down. It’s not clear whether that contributed to the loss, however the next flight will have 50% more hydraulic fluid on board.

F9 v1.1 with hypersonic grid fins

F9 v1.1 with hypersonic grid fins

The barge (or “autonomous spaceport drone ship” (ASDS), as it is called by SpaceX) is modified so it can accurately place itself at a specific location using GPS and four diesel-powered azimuth thrusters. It is unmanned for obvious safety reasons, but placing the recovery point mid-ocean instead of land means that it is closer to the first and second stage separation, the rocket doesn’t have to travel a long distance but just to descent and decelerate, thus minimizing the necessary extra fuel it has to carry.

SpaceX autonomous spaceport drone ship (ASDS)

SpaceX autonomous spaceport drone ship (ASDS)

The ASDS recovery is not just an interim solution until SpaceX rockets are cleared for touchdown over land, but an integral part of SpaceX’s future reusable space system. For the time being, the plan is to recover the first stage on the barge, temporarily welding it in place in order to secure it, and then transferring it to land for refurbishment. In future, especially when the Falcon Heavy R becomes operational, only one of the three F9 cores will return to its launch pad; the other two will be recovered further downrange, probably by some version of ASDS. In the event of an emergency, the Dragon v2 may also need to land on a barge if a problem occurs at a stage where it doesn’t have sufficient fuel to return to land.

You can read more details about future SpaceX operations in this excellent blog post by Stephen C. Smith, which is based on a draft document published by Patrick Air Force base about the environmental impact of the use of Launch Complex 13 at Cape Canaveral, the complex that SpaceX is set to lease.

The next Falcon9 launch is set for the end of this month, and we may see another attempt to land an autonomous rocket on a robotic barge at sea. If successful, it will mark a major milestone in spaceflight.

Unfortunately there is no good footage released yet from this attempt; the video below is from a previous attempt where the rocket performed a soft touchdown at sea:

This is an unofficial cgi video (not made or approved by SpaceX), showing the CRS-5 mission, not necessarily accurate but interesting nonetheless:

If you liked this article, you may also be interested in:

See all the latest robotics news on Robohub, or sign up for our weekly newsletter.

tags: , , , ,

Ioannis K. Erripis joined the ROBOTS association in early 2011 as a news reporter and now leads all technical aspects of the Robohub project, including website design, implementation and branding.
Ioannis K. Erripis joined the ROBOTS association in early 2011 as a news reporter and now leads all technical aspects of the Robohub project, including website design, implementation and branding.

Related posts :

Sponge makes robotic device a soft touch

A simple sponge has improved how robots grasp, scientists from the University of Bristol have found.
07 June 2023, by

#ICRA2023 awards finalists and winners

In this post we bring you all the paper awards finalists and winners presented during the 2023 edition of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA).
05 June 2023, by

Ranking the best humanoid robots of 2023

Is Rosie the Robot Maid from the Jetsons here yet? As more and more companies announce their work towards the affordable humanoid robot, I wanted to create a reference chart.
03 June 2023, by

Robot Talk Episode 51 – James Kell

In this week's episode of the Robot Talk podcast, host Claire Asher chatted to James Kell from Jacobs Engineering UK all about civil infrastructure, nuclear robotics and jet engine inspection.
02 June 2023, by

Automate 2023 recap and the receding horizon problem

“Thirty million developers” are the answer to driving billion-dollar robot startups, exclaimed Eliot Horowitz of Viam last week at Automate.
01 June 2023, by

We are pleased to announce our 3rd Reddit Robotics Showcase!

The 2021 and 2022 events showcased a multitude of fantastic projects from the r/Robotics Reddit community, as well as academia and industry. This year’s event features many wonderful robots including...
30 May 2023, by

©2021 - ROBOTS Association


©2021 - ROBOTS Association